"Proclaim Peace" Season 2, Episode 22 // Jeremiah’s Identity and Madison’s Pluralism: What They Can Teach Us About Peacemaking, With Verlan Lewis
Listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, or watch on YouTube.
Professor Verlan Lewis joins Jen and Patrick to talk about how our identities shape the way we treat one another — and how a pluralistic approach to politics can make room for humility, cooperation, and peace.
Lewis connects peace with remembering our identity as children of God, children of the covenant, and disciples of Christ. From there, the conversation explores how other identities — including political, religious, and community affiliations — can foster belonging and service, or become sources of division when they turn into claims of superiority.
Chapters
(00:00) Welcome and season reflections
(02:56) Introducing guest Verlan Lewis
(04:16) Defining peace
(08:14) Jeremiah 1:5 and identity
(11:27) When group identities help — or hinder — peacemaking
(14:44) Political identity and the left-right spectrum
(19:07) Political pluralism and prophetic counsel
(23:30) Recognizing healthy groups and genuine belonging
(26:14) Diversity, pluralism, and James Madison
(29:36) Majority rule and constitutional protections
(31:12) Balancing difference and unity
(34:18) Keeping political identity in perspective
(38:11) Religious identity and intellectual humility
(40:19) Religious pluralism as a model for political pluralism
(44:01) Personal missions and becoming a peacemaker
(48:11) Prayer, scripture study, and Mr. Krueger’s Christmas
Transcript
Jennifer Thomas (00:00)
Hi friends, welcome to the "Proclaim Peace" podcast, where we review scripture through a lens of peacemaking in the hopes that we can all learn to be better at it. I'm here today, my name is Jennifer Thomas, with my co-host Patrick Mason. How are you doing, Patrick?
Patrick Mason (00:13)
I'm doing all right. It's good to see you, Jen.
Jennifer Thomas (00:15)
Good to see me too. Patrick knows how much I hate doing that intro. It it is a torture for me. But we made it through it and we're here and we're gonna learn together from someone today that we're a conversation we're really excited to have.
Patrick Mason (00:28)
Yeah. I also want to like pause and celebrate like as we get to the end of season two here, the two seasons of "Proclaim Peace." And we've made it all the way through the Old Testament. I would say not so systematically as we've come
Jennifer Thomas (00:42)
No.
Patrick Mason (00:42)
to the to the to the later part of it, but yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (00:45)
And I'm actually really proud of that because I don't think it deserved systemic treatment. I think I think I think that we have exhibited in real time what we really hope that our listeners are doing as they read the scriptures, which is just finding things as they come along. We this doesn't need to be super methodical or perfect, but it one of the great gifts of this year is finding guests who had really distinct views on how they had found peace in the Old Testament. And we were more than happy to let them um lead us where they wanted to go.
Patrick Mason (01:14)
No, and and I've I've learned so much and people have have either illuminated passages that honestly I didn't even know were there, right?
Jennifer Thomas (01:21)
Yeah, yeah.
Patrick Mason (01:22)
I'd never noticed before, or had given whole new readings to to passages that I did know, but had read in a certain way and then and then they just shone new light on it. I think that's gonna be the case today, uh, in in in in this episode.
Jennifer Thomas (01:33)
Yeah, I I agree.
Jennifer Thomas (01:36)
Well, and we're coming to you after a pretty significant transition in our political life. And while that isn't the subject of this podcast, the podcast is a little bit of consequence of the kind of breakdown in peace that we've seen in our civic and public and often even our religious lives over the last 10 or so years. And so that is one of the conversations we're gonna have today is maybe a little bit about how we got where we are and what some of the circumstances that led us into very negative binary thinking and how that impacts our peace as citizens and and as believers and what prophetic wisdom there is out there to help us get out of that mess.
Patrick Mason (02:15)
Yeah, so I I think we have to, as peacemakers, be able to apply these principles, apply this lens to every area of society, right? And politics is not immune to that. we can't just seed it to to to be a realm of never-ending contention and enmity. that that I think it's helpful to look at things from the past and principles from some of our best documents, like the the Constitution and other kinds of really uplifting meditations on on good government, and then apply and combine that with scriptural principles and prophetic teaching to really say, like, no, there's a better way that that we can do this. We don't have to be stuck in the way that we have been doing it recently.
Jennifer Thomas (02:56)
And that unstuckness is gonna require the work of citizens and people. So it's gonna require the work of all the people, all of us who listen and to this podcast and participate in it, as we try to do our best to build peace. And we're gonna talk a little bit today about one of the ways we can do that. And our guest we are excited to have with us is Verlan Lewis. Verlan's currently the Sterling Professor of Constitutional Studies and an associate professor of political science at UVU.
He is a researcher, a teacher, and he also writes about the interaction of ideas and institutions in American politics. Over the last year or so, after having met him, I've enjoyed some really interesting conversations with Verlan. And I know that you too have Patrick and know him. And we really appreciate the thoughtful work that he's doing to to explore how we particularly he's not his work isn't directed specifically at Latter-day Saints, but I think because he is one, he can help us understand how we as Latter-day Saints may might be particularly susceptible to some of the problems he's raising. So he is the author of a book called The Ideas of Power, and then another one called The Myth of Left and Right. And I highly recommend them both. So we would like to welcome to the podcast Verlan Lewis.
Jennifer Thomas (04:07)
Welcome, Verlan We are so grateful to have you with us today and appreciate you taking time to join us on the podcast.
Verlan Lewis (04:12)
Yeah, thanks for having me. I am a fan of the podcast, so happy to be here.
Jennifer Thomas (04:16)
Yay. Okay, we're gonna start with the question we ask all of our listeners or all of our guests. Our listeners hopefully are mentally answering it all the time, but how do you define peace?
Verlan Lewis (04:26)
Yeah, so I think for me, peace is a word that I would use to describe the feeling I have of Christ-like love when I'm thinking about or reflecting on the truth of my identity and who I am as a child of God and as someone who has a savior that has died for me. I think reflecting on that truth brings with brings to me some feelings of gratitude, joy, humility, and love for others that I would describe as peace. so I I think my understanding of peace is informed in a lot of ways by President Nelson's teachings. So of course he's famous for uh his general conference addresses, encouraging us to be peacemakers. But as I think about his ministry and his teachings, there's a few themes that come to mind. I think for different people, they might think of different themes. But for me, there's probably three that stand out of things that he talked about repeatedly. And one was his famous talk about thinking celestial. The second one would be his his teachings and his encouragement, especially to the youth of the church, to prioritize their true identity as children of God, as children of the covenant, and as disciples of Christ. And then the third thing that I think that he emphasized repeatedly, which is connected, I think, to the the topic of this podcast, is being a peacemaker. And I think those three things are related because when we think celestially, we think about God and we think about our relationship to Him, and we think about Christ and our relationship to Him. And when we have those um feelings of love from God and recognizing that He loves us despite our weaknesses and our sins and our imperfections, that's an amazing feeling. And it it turns us right to our who what is our identity? Our identity as children of God, as someone who has a personal savior who's died for them, right? Someone who you know, Jesus Christ lived a perfect life and yet he suffered for my imperfections and my weaknesses. That's an amazing feeling. And when I feel that for myself, I feel that towards other people. and I want to be a peacemaker. I want to love and serve others because I realize that if God loves me in that way, he loves every other person I encounter in that same way. And regardless of their weaknesses and imperfections, he loves them just as much as he loves me. And that makes me want to be more patient and more kind and more forgiving in my relationships with other people. So I think those three themes from President Nelson's teachings are interrelated and they really inform, my understanding of peace. I think another way to think about peace is to think about what it's not. so the opposite of those feelings that I just described, right? The feelings of misery or frustration or anger that comes from enmity, from contention, um, from hostility, right? Those feelings I think would be the opposite of of peace. And I think those feelings come when I forget my true identity, when I focus on the parts of my identity that are not important, when I focus on my worldly identities and forget my relationship to God and how he loves me, then that's when I start feeling the opposite of peace.
But I think when we can remember, right, and remember is such an important word in the scriptures and in our theology, when we can remember who we are and our relationship to God, I find in my own life, and maybe this happens in the lives of your listeners as well, that those feelings of enmity or jealousy or hostility or anger tend to melt away and get replaced with feelings of of love and charity. and so I for me that that is what peace is. And that's why I love the the title of your podcast, "Proclaim Peace." I think what you're doing is just such important work. and so anyway, just happy to be a part of this.
Patrick Mason (08:14)
No, that's that's amazing. Thanks. And and I I really like the way actually you you tied together, I think, some of the themes in President Nelson's ministry in ways that I hadn't quite thought about, right? There's a kind of coherency and some through lines there. I thought about each of those themes individually. Obviously, as you said, he talked about but the ways to to weave those together, uh, I I think is really, really interesting. And so you talked there about identity.
And so as we went back and forth thinking about like what scriptural passage, what what theme did we want to emerge here, you you immediately went to to Jeremiah one five, which I think is a scripture that's familiar to to a lot of Latter-day Saints, and speaks directly to this question of identity. So what is it about Jeremiah one five? Maybe remind us what it is in case people missed that week in Sunday school. Uh and and and what is it that draws you to that passage?
Verlan Lewis (09:04)
Yeah, so I can I can just read it here, I've got in front of me. in Jeremiah chapter one, verse five, the Lord says to Jeremiah, Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee, and before thou cameest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations. And I love this verse because the Lord is telling Jeremiah that he knows Jeremiah individually and personally, and he knows everything about him. He knew Jeremiah before he was born into this world.
And, you know, as you hinted at, Patrick, as Latter-day Saints, we have an understanding of a premortal existence. And this verse is often used to describe this relationship that we have with God before we are born. But I think another great thing another great thing about this verse is it's teaching us that the most important things about us, the most important things about our identity, are eternal.
And they existed before we were born. So if we go back to you know President Nelson's teachings about identity, being a child of God, we were a spirit son or daughter of God before we were born in this world. We were a child of heavenly parents in the premortal existence, and that's a powerful thing, and that doesn't change when we come into this world. We covenanted to follow Jesus Christ before we came to this earth. In fact, that's the reason we're here. Because he said, I will go and be your savior, and you can come down into this world and have this experience. And so that's something that is true of all of us. It's universal. We are all equally the children of God. We are all equally people who have made covenants to follow Jesus Christ. And so those important identities stay with us. All the things that are unimportant about us are things that are imposed upon us or that we develop or accrete during our mortal experience. Right? So the things that don't matter to God, but unfortunately matter to the world are things like, well, how much stuff do you own, right? Your material possessions, what's your economic class? What's your social status? How much power do you have? all of those things that don't matter to God are the things that we develop, unfortunately in this life and we focus on. And so I think remembering who we are, uh, and the most important parts of our identity, uh, they've been with us forever. And I think that's just a really important thing to remember. And that's something that I love that the Lord is focusing on in that verse when he's speaking to Jeremiah.
Jennifer Thomas (11:27)
So this is great. And I identity is obviously in many ways core to who we are. And we build identities, to your point. We've got this supernal identity as children of God, but then we've also got all these identities that we accrue. And some some that you talked about are obviously bad, just an identity based on what we have. But I think there are a lot of intermediate identities.
Verlan Lewis (11:47)
Yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (11:47)
Like my identity that I feel around my faith, or specifically I will just say I'm part of a ward that just blended. I had a real identity around the ward that I belonged to and it disappeared, right? And it was a good identity. we have identities around family, like what it means to to be a Walker or a Thomas, right? And uh
Verlan Lewis (12:04)
Yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (12:04)
identities around politics, culture, community. It can extend out into lots of different ways. Notre Dame football, right?
Patrick Mason (12:08)
Notre Dame football.
Jennifer Thomas (12:10)
So I'd love to have you share with us a little bit about when these identities can give us a really positive sense of purpose and belonging because I think they're necessary. I I couldn't agree more that our foundational identity needs to be a child of God, but also to work with other people or to feel a sense of belonging, we also have to accumulate other kinds of identities. And so I'd love to have you share with us how you think that is effective and when that can be good, and what are the qualities of that kind of sense of identification that that it can become a barrier to us. What what flips? You know, when is it
Verlan Lewis (12:43)
Yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (12:43)
good? And when does it flip to not being so helpful to us and being a barrier?
Verlan Lewis (12:46)
Yeah, what a great question. So I think as human beings, we are um tribal beings. We need to belong to groups. We need to feel a sense of identity and belonging with other people in this world. And so it's not just those premortal identities um that matter. There's other important identities also in our lives. And I think one way to think about that, whether or not these are healthy identities or unhealthy identities, is to think about what does this identity make me feel? Or what does this identity make me want to do? And so if this is an identity that makes me want to love and serve other people, if it's an identity that gives me a sense of gratitude, humility, if it makes me feel peace and want to be a peacemaker, then I think that's a great identity, right?
And I think there's lots of examples of that in the world. I think the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is an example of an institution that provides an identity for people that causes them to feel that way and to want to serve in that way. I think Mormon Women for Ethical Government is another group, another organization in our society that helps the members who identify with that organization to feel that way and to want to love and serve others.
I think where we have to be careful or concerned is if we have identities that do the opposite. If this is an identity that makes us feel enmity towards our fellow human beings, that puts us in competition with them, that makes us want to see them fail so that we can see ourselves as above them or better than them.
And there's lots of identities like that in the world today. And I I know we're gonna get into this a little bit, but my brother and I co-authored a book on The Myth of Left and Right, where we argue that identities based on a one-dimensional ideological spectrum are two examples of those kinds of harmful identities because of the way that they cause us to get to a point of intellectual arrogance and where because they cause us to want to um defeat or destroy or um be in contention with our fellow human beings.
Patrick Mason (14:44)
So can I follow up on that? We're recording this a week after the elections. Uh
and you know, people feel strongly, either good or bad, about what what what happened in in those elections and we do this, you know, on a regular basis, right?
Jennifer Thomas (14:57)
So strongly.
Patrick Mason (14:59)
And so talk talk about that. I mean, maybe we would have gotten to this later, but I but I just want to jump in right now in the sense of like, okay, what about political identities, right? In in this country in the United States, that generally is one of two parties, right? Obviously, there's a few other options, but but generally it's one of two options. And we've even been counseled by church leaders to get involved, right? Be be be civically engaged, join political parties. That's not a bad thing. We haven't been told not to join parties, right? Uh
Verlan Lewis (15:27)
Yeah.
Patrick Mason (15:28)
Most people who engage in politics are gonna have a partisan identity. And
so and in elections there's winners and there's losers. And you are trying to defeat the other person because you think your ideas are better or you think you you know, your your party will better serve the common good or or something like that. So how how do you square what you just said, which I totally agree with, right? And then I think, well, how does that actually work in a political system where I'm a partisan?
Verlan Lewis (15:55)
Yeah, that's a great question. the the prophets have rightly encouraged us to get involved politically, to participate in political parties, to run for political office, to vote, to do all of those things. And that's an important part of being a citizen in a democracy. But I think we also have to be careful about which identities we use when we do that. And so I don't think there's any harm in identifying with a political party like the Democratic Party or the Republican Party. But the problem comes in is when we try to place ourselves and others on a one-dimensional ideological left-right spectrum. And I think that's where the damage comes in. Because that way of thinking about the world is misleading.
Patrick Mason (16:34)
Wh when you say one dimensional left, right, so say more about what what do you mean there? How how would you unpack that phrase?
Verlan Lewis (16:38)
Y Yeah, as you probably know, just reading the news or scrolling through social media or having any kind of political conversation with a friend, you'll frequently hear terms that refer to a one-dimensional ideological spectrum. You'll hear people talk about the left and the right.
Progressives on the left, conservatives on the right. That's the way that everyone talks about politics today. That hasn't always been the case. That's actually a r relatively recent phenomenon in human history, and it's a relatively recent phenomenon in American history, just over the past several decades, uh has that one-dimensional framing entered our political discourse and our political lexicon. So that's what's new, and I think that's one of the things that's driving a lot of the uh misunderstanding and a lot of the contention in our politics.
Because what a one-dimensional spectrum says is that there's just one issue in politics. After all, a one-dimensional spectrum can by definition only measure one thing. Right? Yeah,
Jennifer Thomas (17:32)
One thing. Mm-hmm.
Patrick Mason (17:33)
Ha ha ha.
Verlan Lewis (17:34)
so like a thermometer, right, measures one thing, temperature. It can go up or it can go down. It's just a line, right? That makes sense because you're measuring one thing. But politics is not about one thing, it's about a lot of different issues.
And the problem with thinking in terms of left-right spectrum is it causes us to think, well, yes, there are hundreds of issues in politics, but they all must be somehow philosophically connected and grow out of one of two philosophies. And so once you make your choice about the one big thing that determines whether you're a progressive on the left or a conservative on the right, then you know that you're correct about everything because all of your party's issue positions flow out of that one issue, philosophy or that one world view.
Patrick Mason (18:12)
And maybe you don't even have to think about all those things because you already know what the answer is, right?
Verlan Lewis (18:16)
Exactly, that you're correct. And not only do you know that you're correct about everything, you know that the other party is wrong about everything. Because they chose the wrong side of the spectrum, and their issue positions are all informed by the wrong philosophy. So rather than entering into the public square, as our church leaders rightfully encourage us to do, as people who think, well,
We're all fallen human beings. Every person I encounter is gonna be correct about some things and wrong about some things. Every political party I encounter is gonna be correct about some things and wrong about some things. The left-right spectrum tells us a lie. It tell it gives us the uh false assumption of omniscience, that I know I'm correct about everything because I'm on the correct side of this one-dimensional line.
And I know everyone else who's not with me on this side of the line is wrong about everything. And I think there's some great quotes, if I can read, I just came with a couple quotes from
Jennifer Thomas (19:06)
Please.
Verlan Lewis (19:07)
the first presidency in encouraging members of the church to participate in politics, but to do so in what I would call a pluralistic way. And we can talk about what that means. but recognizing that there's many issues in politics and not just one. So the first, the first quote I'll give is from President Oaks, who gave this wonderful address, I think it was Easter 2023, on defending the divinely inspired constitution. And he said in this talk, quote, there are many political issues, right? So he the first thing he says is pluralism. There's many issues, not just one. And no party, no platform or individual candidate can satisfy all personal preferences.
Each citizen must therefore decide which issues are most important to him or her at any particular time. Then members should seek inspiration on how to exercise their influence according to their individual priorities. This process will not be easy. It may require changing party support or candidate choices, even from election to election. So there's a couple truths that President Oaks is teaching here. First, he's teaching pluralism.
He's teaching us that politics is not one-dimensional, it's multidimensional. There are many issues, not just one. Secondly, he's teaching us that because political parties are man-made institutions, they are not perfect. No party has a monopoly on truth. No party fully encompasses the gospel of Jesus Christ. And he's also teaching us that as man-made institutions, these parties inevitably evolve over time. And the issue positions that they take or the principles that they embody at one moment will be different.
From what they were 10 or 15 or 20 years ago and what they will be 10 or 15 or 20 years in the future. And as a result, as disciples of Jesus Christ who are trying to bring to bear our understanding of true gospel principles, this might mean that we need to change which party we support from election to election. Around the same time, the first presidency came out with a great letter on encouraging members of the church to participate in politics.
And it says many of the same things, but I'll read it because I just think it's so good. The first presidency said in this letter: some principles compatible with the gospel may be found in various political parties. So there are various political parties, and every political party has some things that are true about it. Of course, that means every political party has some things that are false about it as well, right? These are not perfect institutions. Members should also study candidates carefully and vote for those who have demonstrated integrity, compassion and service to others regardless of party affiliation. Merely voting a straight ticket or voting based on tradition without careful study of candidates and their positions on important issues is a threat to democracy and inconsistent with revealed standards. So I think the implication of President Oaks' teachings and the first presidency's teachings here is that the left-right spectrum is a threat to democracy and is contrary to revealed teachings because the left-right spectrum says, well, one party's always on one side of the spectrum, and one party's always on the other side, and there's just one issue, and one party's correct about everything, and one party's wrong about everything. And as long as they stay on their side of the spectrum, then they don't change. That's not what the the prophet teaches. The prophet teaches, no, politics is about many things, it's not about one thing. The parties are imperfect and they're constantly uh evolving. And so I think as members of the church and as citizens of democracies everywhere.
We need to get rid of the false monistic left-right spectrum and start thinking about politics in terms of pluralism. That politics about many issues and politics is never perfect, but we're always trying to improve our politics on the margins.
Jennifer Thomas (22:36)
So I really appreciate this. And I I think actually um parties are a really good way to think about this. we've talked about identity, we've talked about how having a correct sense of identity is productive of peace, an incorrect sense of identity is actually destructive of peace. And our parties have driven us here. They've been sort of, I would say, for the last 10, maybe even 15 years in American society, as people have dechurched, as they've disconnected from social groups. It's become the one of the major ways that people identify themselves, one of the major identities and groups that the parties are acting as groups that try to draw people toward them in this binary way. I would love if you'd share with us a little bit about how our listeners can become wiser. What are the hallmarks of a group that is offering them genuine belonging, a genuine opportunity to make a difference in the world? Because I think a lot of people enter into politics with a real desire to make a difference, right? So genuine belonging, a genuine desire to make a difference, and a genuine opportunity to be more productive of peace, because I think groups and identities can do that, as opposed to groups that do the opposite, that are using, are being manipulative or being destructive of peace or are using belonging to accomplish their own aims. Like, what are some of the hallmarks of that that we could our listeners can start to look for as they try to make sure that they're not identifying with groups that are ultimately going to be destructive to their soul or to their peace.
Verlan Lewis (24:01)
So I think I would just reiterate a little bit of what I said earlier about think through what does this identity do for me? How does it make me feel? How does it make me feel towards my fellow human beings, my fellow citizens? Do I want to serve them and love them, or do I want to dominate and destroy them? But I would also say think about is this identity or this is this group monistic or pluralistic? And I can unpack what I mean by that.
Is it monistic in the sense that it sets up a fundamental opposition that says those of us in our group have a monopoly on truth and we are correct about everything? And if you're not part of our group, you are wrong about everything. Right? Or is it a pluralistic group or identity that says our group stands for some principles that we think are important in a pluralistic world? We recognize that we do not have a monopoly on truth. There are other individuals, groups, and institutions out there.
That also have truth that is important to listen to, and that we can work together with them on shared concerns or on common ground because there is that shared truth. And I think the Church of Jesus Christ is a great example of being a pluralistic organization in this way. The Church of Jesus Christ says, we believe in the restoration of the gospel of Jesus Christ. But we do not claim that everyone who is not a member of our church is entirely evil or benighted, that every other religious group has some truth. And in fact, I love the way that President Hinckley talked about missionary work. He said, What we do with missionary work is we say to people, come see what we have and see if there's anything that we can add to the truth and the knowledge that you already have. And what a great way to approach religious difference in a pluralistic society. And I think something could be said similarly for operating in a political world. If you form a political group or you identify with a political group,
Reach out to other groups in a pluralistic society and say, hey, we recognize that you have a lot of good going for you. This is what we're talking about, this is what's important to us. Let's see if there's anything that we can add to the truth and the knowledge that you already have. And let's see if we can work together on certain common principles to build common ground in that way. And I think that's a much uh a better way to approach politics that's much more conducive to peacemaking rather than uh to contention and conflict and violence.
Patrick Mason (26:14)
That's terrific. So you're telling me that I have to hold my identity as a Notre Dame football fan lightly. Uh I can't grasp it too tightly.
Jennifer Thomas (26:22)
Just between January and August we'll give you a reprieve. Yeah.
Patrick Mason (26:26)
Okay. I only have to do that eight months of the year. Okay. But yeah. Okay. Thank you very much. All right.
Verlan Lewis (26:31)
As long as it doesn't make you hate Miami fans, I'm okay with it. Got it
Patrick Mason (26:34)
Yeah. I'm working on this. So it's uh I'm working on it.
Jennifer Thomas (26:41)
It's been a trying period for you, Patrick.
Patrick Mason (26:43)
But we're on the we're on the upswing. Okay. I we we could turn this into a a football podcast real quick, but I'm gonna I'm gonna bring it back. I'm gonna bring it back. All right.
Jennifer Thomas (26:48)
No, we can't.
Patrick Mason (26:52)
Okay. What is what's the difference between diversity and pluralism?
Verlan Lewis (26:56)
That's a good way of thinking about it. I think they're similar in a lot of ways. I think pluralism recognizes that you're always gonna be a minority in the world. because right, you can have diversity that has one group that's a majority and then lots of smaller minority groups. but the way I talk about pluralism, and at least in my scholarship, talking about constitutional pluralism.
This comes a lot from actually the Federalist Papers. So if you read James Madison, one of the reasons that he tried to give for why Americans should ratify the Constitution and adopt it was because it would create pluralism. So part of the problem that was going on during the critical period under the state government, under the state constitutions, is that these republics that were created after the revolution were too small. They didn't have enough factions, as he called them. They didn't have enough groups.
And what ended up happening is one group or faction would end up in the majority and dominate and violate the rights of minority groups. and so he had in mind things like inflationary monetary policy in Rhode Island that violated the economic rights of creditors, or uh disenfranchisement legislation in Pennsylvania that violated the religious rights of Quakers. So he had in mind these concerns that minority groups were being oppressed in these ways. A large republic, Madison argued brings in pluralism, where you have dozens of groups, not just two or three or four. And in a pluralistic society, no one group will ever have a majority. And so you have to recognize that my group, my affiliations, my identities will always be a minority identity. Well that's actually a good thing, Madison said.
Because it leads to a kind of humility and a kind of deference to others and a toleration for others that you might not have if you thought, well, as long as I as long as I can just get in majority, then I'm gonna have power and then I can work my will or work my way. But understanding that you're always gonna be a minority leads you to adopt certain constitutional principles that limit government's power from exercising tyranny. And so these are, in my mind, the five fundamentals that President Oaks talks about in his 2023 address. Where if you really believe in pluralism, if that's your understanding of the world, you're gonna want the separation of powers because you want to limit government's power. You're gonna want federalism, you're gonna want a protection of individual rights, you're gonna want the rule of law and popular sovereignty, you're gonna want all these things that check government's power to
exercise tyranny over other people. So I think in a political context, I like to use the word pluralism because it implies this idea that we need to always understand we're gonna be in the minority and always understand that we should protect other people's rights just as we would want them to protect our own rights.
Patrick Mason (29:36)
Yeah, I I I love that. This has been front of mind for me. the last week I in my graduate seminar, I read a great book with with my students. it's Adam Jortner's book called No Place for Saints, which which is about the anti Mormon violence in Missouri in 1833. It's terrific. And this is exactly the problem that the Latter day Saints ran into in in Missouri, right? Is it was the fear of what Madison was trying to solve.
Right. In some ways we say, we love democracy, we love democracy, and we we do love democracy. but he was he was afraid of excess democracy, essentially the tyranny of the majority, right? Where with no guardrails, just a bunch of people could say, we don't like the other people, and they could go beat them up and do whatever they want with them because they're in the majority.
Jennifer Thomas (30:19)
They're the majority, yeah.
Patrick Mason (30:20)
And and uh what is what it seems you're suggesting to me, and what the constitution does and what Madison and the others and and the reason we've had a successful republic, for for two and a half centuries, is because it's not just pure democracy. There are other things involved, right? And and and it seems like that's what President Oaks has been talking about as well. Then so when you're talking about pluralism, it's not just pure majority rule, right? There are other there are other things going on.
Verlan Lewis (30:44)
Exactly. Yeah. Because uh there it's a constitutional democracy. There's restraints on what the majority can do. There's the the democracy is restrained by certain constitutional restraints and that's a that's a good thing.
Jennifer Thomas (30:58)
So so I really love the idea. I do a lot of work in pluralism. And to the point of a lot of what you've talked about, Verlan, I think the gift of of a p living in a pluralistic society like ours is that it has created protections for differences, right? And one
of the reasons that I I've thought a lot about what President Oaks has written and said and in so many ways, I I think that even though a place like the United States in human history is so unnatural, it is so unnatural to have a country that is not organized around religion or organized around nationality or just geographic where people were born, right? to me, it seems almost that much more reflective of what governance looks like amongst all of God's children. Because God has created these children of infinite worth who He by definition has created in really diverse ways. We look different, we think differently, we have different skills and gifts, native, you know, just native capacities.
And so I've love the idea that that we've tried to create and are trying to preserve, and and President Oaks is obviously deeply trying to preserve a governance that allows for this vast range of identities, right? That this vast ranges of differences. But there's this tension, right?
Verlan Lewis (32:14)
Yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (32:14)
So share with us how we balance attention between just giving over to and celebrating this diversity and we're all different and it's all great and everybody's gonna be their own thing to getting to a place where we can actually function, e pluribis unum, right? Where we can have a unity, a functional unity. And I think we're practicing this in the United States. But for those of us on this call, the three of us, and for all of the people listening, I think for us, the goal is Zion.
So we're practicing this politically and civically, but what we are aiming for is a society where this will be the way we think. So I'd love to hear your thoughts about how can we balance from your perspective, diversity and unity and make that really work as children of God.
Verlan Lewis (32:55)
Yeah, I think this goes back to President Nelson's teachings about focusing on the most important identities. because I think if that is where our focus is, then that's something that unifies us, right? So if you think about your most important identities, your premortal identities, child of God, a d child of the covenant, disciple of Christ, these are things that you share equally with every other human being on the planet, right? So that's something you have in common with them.
If you focus on the things that don't matter, right, the things that the world would tell you to focus on, how much money do you have in your bank account? how prestigious is your job or career? Um, you know, how how much power do you have in organizations, right? Those are inevitably unequal things. Every person that you encounter in the world is gonna be different from you in that way.
And the tendency and the the temptation is to create hierarchies where we try and place people somewhere in this hierarchy. right, do you have more money or less money? Do you have more social status or less social status? Do you have more power than me or less power than me? And that inevitably sets up an enmity, right? This is President Benson's teachings about pride, that enmity is the root of pride because it essentially pits you against other people. He quotes C. S. Lewis in that great talk on the Universal Sin of Pride, where C. S. Lewis says something along the lines of, you know, pride gets nothing out of having something. Pride only gets something out of having more than the next guy.
It's always in comparison to someone else. And when we focus on those other things, those other identities, we're always gonna be focusing on what's different from us and how can we have more than someone else or put someone else down and raise ourselves up. So I think President Nelson's teachings are really important there. And I might just quote from him again, if you don't mind, because I think he just says it so much better uh than I ever can. So in this talk on identity, he says, quote, there are various labels that may be very important to you, of course. Please do not misunderstand me. I am not saying that other designations and identifiers are not significant. I am simply saying that no identifier should displace, replace, or take priority over these three enduring designations child of God, child of the covenant, and disciple of Jesus Christ.
Any identifier that is not compatible with these three basic designations will ultimately let you down. Other labels will disappoint you in time because they do not have the power to lead you toward eternal life in the celestial kingdom of God. Worldly identifiers will never give you a vision of who you can ultimately become. They will never affirm your divine DNA or your unlimited divine potential.
So he says it's fine to have other identities. It's fine to focus on these other things to an extent, but never to the point where those replace the th the most important or paramount identities. And he actually gives two examples in the talk of people of things that might cause us to do that. He talks about national identity and political identity.
So he says, you might think of yourself, I'll just quote him again. He says, for example, if you are identified mainly as an American, those who are not Americans may think, I know everything there is to know about you, and attribute erroneous beliefs to you. If you identify yourself by your political affiliation, you will be instantly categorized as having certain beliefs. So I don't know anyone who believes everything that their preferred political party presently embraces. So again, President Nelson is teaching against the fallacy of monism. He says, one, no party is going to fully satisfy any one person's personal preferences, right? Because there isn't just one issue, and it's not as if all the hundreds of issues are bound together by a progressive philosophy or a conservative philosophy. That's just nonsense. That's just not true. So he says, first of all, and he says what they presently represent.
Which is, or what they presently embrace, which is recognizing that the parties are going to change. And so I I don't think President Nelson is saying, don't get involved in politics. He's not saying don't identify with the political party. He's saying, no, do that. Join a political party, vote, participate, campaign, do all those things, but hold those identities at arm's length. The Republican Party will not save you. The Democratic Party will not save you. They are not vehicles of salvation. And be willing to recognize that when they change, you might agree with that change, you might disagree with that change, and you might change which party you're s you support from election to election. Don't buy into the fallacy of monism. Don't buy into the fallacy of left-right thinking that says, aha, one party is the good party because they're on the correct side of the spectrum and all their ideas and attitudes and values are bound together by a philosophy. That's that's a dangerous thing because I think what happens for a lot of people, and I I think the reason that President Nelson used parties as an example.
Too many people, instead of trying to figure out, okay, I have my standards as a disciple of Jesus Christ, and I have the scriptures and what the prophets teach and what Christ taught. Now I'm going to evaluate this candidate or this party or this group according to those standards. A lot of people do the opposite. They say, Well, this is what my party is saying, or this is what my party leaders are telling me. And does it match, does my religion match that? And if not, I'm gonna try and twist my religion or my religious beliefs to fit what my political group is telling me is important. And it should be the exact other way around. We should be influences for good within our political parties, reforming them and changing them for the better to better reflect the teachings of Jesus Christ.
Patrick Mason (38:11)
Can I ask how does this work in terms of holding certain identities lightly or or not too closely or at arm's length, for the sake of pluralism and living together? Uh how does this work for religious identity? Right? where we say, I think I think most people, even the even the the most partisan people would say, okay, I know that like in the next life, like I'm, you know, probably not gonna be a Democrat, right? or something like that. But religious identity is different.
Jennifer Thomas (38:37)
I bet there are people, Patrick, who would consider that blasphemy.
Patrick Mason (38:41)
I know, I just uh forgive me, right?
Verlan Lewis (38:42)
Right.
Patrick Mason (38:44)
But religious identity is different, right?
Verlan Lewis (38:46)
Yeah.
Patrick Mason (38:47)
And of course, you know, our church makes claims to truth. Lots of other religions make claims to truth, and not just proximate truth, but eternal truth.
Verlan Lewis (38:56)
Yeah.
Patrick Mason (38:56)
So, so how do we think about those identities and then how to navigate that within a pluralistic social, cultural, political realm? Because we aren't in heaven yet.
Verlan Lewis (39:07)
Yeah. Well and I think this is what President Nelson is getting at when he talks about your identity as a child of the covenant. That right, th this is an important identity, right? That if you're a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, that is an ultimately important identity that you should cling to and feel very strongly about, while at the same time recognizing that you just because you might belong to a church that has authorized priesthood keys, does not make you omniscient, and it doesn't make you perfect. That you are a fallen creature, and we all are as children of God. We are all fallen. And so I think it should imbue us with a humility in the public square that says I have lots of opinions about lots of different things in politics, in religion, in sports, all right.
And I might be right about some of those opinions, and I'm definitely wrong about some of those opinions, and that's okay. And I should treat every other person in the public square in the same way. So I think it it imbues with us with a sense of intellectual humility and recognizing: look, I want to hear what you have to say. And if I can replace some of my error with truth that you have, all for the better. This isn't a status competition. It's not like, well, I want my team to win and I I can't stand it if you were right and I was wrong. It's like, no, no, no. If I'm wrong and you're right, awesome. Tell me about it. I want to hear about it. I want to learn from you. I want to be persuaded. and I think that applies in many, many realms of life. Interestingly, as as you brought up this question about religious pluralism. So to go back to James Madison, in Federalist 51, he actually points to religious pluralism as a model for political pluralism.
So he writes about how there's this strange thing in American politics called religious freedom. And it had never really existed anywhere in the world at any time in human history. Now, why do the Americans believe in religious freedom? That's crazy. The state should tell you what to believe and should enforce it. And he says actually the the people who colonized the United States didn't come with ideas about religious toleration.
Now they may have been concerned about what the way they were treated in the old country, but it didn't mean that they came with ideas about we're going to allow everyone else religious freedom in our new communities. So how did how did Americans get here in 1787? And and why was that a thing? Why didn't the national government, why didn't the Constitution, which he had a big part in drafting and and a big part in getting ratified, why didn't it include an established national church? And he says, Well, it's interesting, in the American case, what happened was there was too many religions. There was too much pluralism. That no one religious group could dominate and impose its will on everyone else. And so the religion the reason Americans had religious freedom wasn't because they necessarily had principled ideas about the good of religious freedom. It's because it was the d default. They couldn't do anything else. There was no one group that had the majority to impose their will.
And he says, likewise, we should do the same thing in politics. We should have so many different political groups and factions that no one political group will be able to dominate, and that everyone will look for safety and security in a limited constitutional government. Now, some people misinterpret my co-author and I when we talk about that and they say, well, you're against the two-party system. Like, not actually. We've always had a two-party system in America. What's new in American politics is left-right thinking.
That's relatively new. We imported that from Russia in the 1930s. That's a new way of viewing the world. For for most of American history, we've had two parties, and but we didn't try to put them on a one-dimensional line. We didn't pretend that they were left-wing or right-wing. We didn't think monistically, we thought pluralistically. And so we recognize the truth, which is that each of our two parties is a coalition, a heterogeneous coalition of lots of individuals and groups and factions with lots of different ideas and values, and that's okay. As long as you say, hey, we disagree on a lot of different things, but we can agree on a few things and let's work together to attract try to achieve common ends on those few things.
And Americans recognized that our two parties were baskets of issue positions, some of which they agreed with, some of which they disagreed with, and that was okay. And they would identify with and prefer one party over the other if it had more of the stuff they liked than the other party. But they also might change which party they support from election to election when those issue positions change. The new thing in American politics that's emerged in the last several decades in our society is left-right thinking that says, no, no, no, there's some philosophical coherence to all these issue positions that the two parties have.
And that my party must be correct about everything and the other party must be wrong about everything. And so the only thing to do in that situation, of course, it makes sense. Dominate and destroy. If you really are belonging to a group that is wholly enlightened and wholly good, and you are really are facing another group that is wholly evil and wholly benighted, well then you should try to destroy and dominate them. that that's that's the logic of left right thinking and that's I think one of the reasons why our politics is so vitriolic and so hate filled today.
Jennifer Thomas (44:01)
So as we start to think about bringing this conversation to a conclusion, I'd like to jump back to what we were talking about at the part at the beginning, if you're okay with that. And
Verlan Lewis (44:09)
Yeah.
Jennifer Thomas (44:10)
we've talked a lot about the things that are pulling us apart and a lot about s kind of what it means to be part of a group, et cetera. We talked and we opened this conversation with the scripture about God knowing each of us individually, knowing what we were made of, knowing what we were made for. And I would just love if you would share with us some of your concluding thoughts about what you believe that scripture. You chose it, you wanted to share it with us. It really clearly resonates with you, obviously. So, what does it mean to move in a world knowing that God chose you to do good things? and how how does that impact how you do your work? And how would you want it to impact how our listeners do their work as peacemakers?
Verlan Lewis (44:51)
Yeah, well I think that means everything. As I kind of mentioned at the beginning, when I think about the infinite love that I feel from God despite all of my weaknesses and sins and imperfections, it's transformative.
It melts away feelings of anger and contention and hostility that I might have towards members of my family or of my neighborhood or of my church congregation or of my workplace, right? Those things tend to melt away as I feel the love that God has for me and recognizing that in other people and giving them the grace that that God gives to me. I think it's also so powerful to recognize that God has particular missions for each of us individually that are unique to us and who we are as his spirit sons and daughters. And I think for me, I just feel so blessed and grateful to live at this time in world history, to live in this particular place that I live. And
To be alive when, yes, the world is hard, yes, there's lots of conflict, yes, there's lots of contention and anger and hostility. But at the same time, he's given us the resources and the teachings through scriptures and through prophets and through revelation to overcome that. And that I think so I see that in my own life that, like, wow, this is what President Oaks is teaching, this is what President Nelson is teaching.
I can take that and be a light into the world to help other people give up on monism and embrace pluralism. And that really informs the way that I approach my scholarship and forms the way I approach my teaching, um and it informs the way that I interact with people in my life. And I think it's beautiful. And I think everyone um can do the same thing and I'm sure does the same thing to some regard. Try to understand what it is, what's the mission that God has for you. I think for those for most of your listeners who, you know, are listening to a podcast called "Proclaim Peace," I'm guessing that they have correctly figured out that they need to be peacemakers in the world.
And that's an important part of their they have unique gifts, unique skills, unique talents t that are unique to them that can help bring peace into this world, that they can be bridge builders and peacemakers. And so I I just think that's a that's a beautiful thing and I'm grateful for what you two are doing to to promote that message.
Jennifer Thomas (46:58)
I love that a lot. I've thought about that scripture over the years. and I think sometimes we as Latter day Saints tend to read it sometimes as a look, we were chosen, it's all good, we've got this, we're on top of things. And I as I've gotten older, what I really read it as is that God knew me and that the ways that he manifests the chosenness is to have given me the tools, if I only decide to use them, to become what he needs in the world. And that's a very different approach than I am here, I'm arrived, I've got it all, to I knowing that God knew me, I need to look around myself and figure out what tools has He given me, whether it's the restored gospel, covenants, whatever, to bring peace to others. And I'm just so, so appreciative the way you've shared this idea with us today.
Verlan Lewis (47:41)
Well, and if I can just say one quick thing on the flip side of that, God has not only given us our unique talents and strengths, but he's given us our unique foibles and weaknesses, right? That God gives unto men weakness that they might be humble. And so I think we need to accept, you know, our own weaknesses and say, you know what, that's okay that God gave me this weakness, as long as I use that weakness to make myself humble.
And once I become humble, then I can be an instrument in the Lord's hands to do his work. If I'm if I'm proud, then I can't. But if I'm meek and humble, then I can I can do that work.
Patrick Mason (48:11)
It's amazing. Well, Verlan this has been great. As we sign off, we we wanna ask you the question we ask everybody. In this world of conflict and sometimes contention, how and where do you find peace?
Verlan Lewis (48:23)
Yeah, so I'll give you maybe two answers. One one cliche answer, but it's true. And then um
Jennifer Thomas (48:29)
Love
Verlan Lewis (48:29)
maybe one bizarre answer because it will be memorable to your audience.
Jennifer Thomas (48:32)
We love those two.
Verlan Lewis (48:34)
So the first answer is is the primary answer. I find peace in personal prayer and scripture study. And I think I find peace in that way because when I kneel down before God, I can't help but think of my relationship to him. I can't help but feel the love that he has for me and how that changes the way I think about myself.
And when I think about the love that he has for me, I recognize the love that he has for my fellow brothers and sisters, and it changes the way that I treat them and feel about them. And it brings peace into my soul. And the same thing with the scriptures. When I read the words of God through his prophets, I'm focused on the most important truth about my identity, and that changes the way I feel about myself and about other people. So that's the cliche answer, but it's true. The more bizarre answer I will give you is a um Christmas-themed answer.
My favorite Christmas movie to watch, and you're I my kids groan when I get it out, and your listeners will think that's a terrible movie to watch because it's low budget and tacky.
But it brings me peace, is Mr. Kruger's Christmas. So it's this nineteen seventies production, you maybe you've seen it, and it's very low budget and it's bell bottoms and striped clothing and it's not the most aesthetically pleasing thing. But I love Jimmy Stewart's performance in that movie and I I love the story of Willie Kruger, the custodian, who has a change of heart about how he feels about himself and the way he feels about the people that he interacts with because he recognizes who he is and who loves him. And I just think it's a beautiful story.
Patrick Mason (50:02)
That's amazing. I show that to my priest quorum every year. I force them to watch it. And
Verlan Lewis (50:04)
Okay. Okay.
Patrick Mason (50:06)
I cry in Priest Quorum every year. But like that scene
Verlan Lewis (50:09)
I can't help it.
Patrick Mason (50:10)
when he approaches the the manger. I mean,
Verlan Lewis (50:12)
Yes.
Patrick Mason (50:13)
so glad they cast Jimmy Stewart for that. It is uh it's
Verlan Lewis (50:15)
It's the best.
Patrick Mason (50:16)
pretty epic. Yeah. Well Verlan thank you so much. What a great way to end. And Merry Christmas, everyone, whenever you're listening to this. Uh and so grateful for everything that you brought and all your insights. really glad to have you on the podcast.
Verlan Lewis (50:27)
Thanks, Jen. Thanks, Patrick.
Jennifer Thomas (50:34)
Thanks for listening to this episode of "Proclaim Peace." To hear more, you can subscribe on a podcast app of your choice or on YouTube. You can always find full show notes or transcriptions at proclaimpeace.org.
Patrick Mason (50:48)
"Proclaim Peace" is a partnership between MWEG and Waymakers. You can learn more about Waymakers at waymakers.us. Thanks again for listening and we'll see you next time.

